Thursday, November 5, 2009

New Educational Media Technology

Read, Brock. "Duke U. Assess iPod Experiment and Finds It Worked--in Some Courses." The Chronicle of Higher Education 51.43 (2005): A28. Education Full Text. Web. 5 Nov. 2009.

Brock Read examines the results of the Duke University experiment in which the university gave each incoming freshman an iPod Touch. As the year progressed, the technology center interviewed and re-interviewed students and faculty about their impressions of the iPod's usefulness. About 75% of the students used the device in at least one class, and the classes were in a number of disciplines. Read notes that the results were mixed, and while students took advantage of the ability to record lectures, professors reported that the sound was of poor quality and that it was hard to combine audio and text. In addition, there were licensing issues with some companies which prevented materials from being downloaded. Many professors did use the device to complement course lectures and materials, and praised the device for its small size and usability. Read reports that next year Duke will only give iPod Touches to students who enroll in classes that had high iPod use previously, and gives the link to the full report on the Duke website.

Coombs, Karen. "The Mobile iRevolution." Library Journal (1976) Fall 2008: 28. Education Full Text. Web. 5 Nov. 2009.

Karen Coombs believes that mobile broadband is the wave of the future and the future is now. Libraries need to reach iPod and iPhone by optimizing their websites for Safari, creating applications for the devices and uploading podcasts on iTunes U (a valuable tool that is rarely discussed). In addition, she reveals that the University of Houston Libraries are currently working on all those issues, and on expanding their reach across the campus. She points out there are challenges in keeping up with the rapidly changing technology but that the reward in reaching users in worth it.

Auchincloss, Conrad, and Thomas McIntyre. "iPod "Teach": Increased Access to Technological Learning Supports Through the Use of the iPod Touch." Journal of Special Education Technology 23.2 (2008): 45-9. Education Full Text. Web. 5 Nov. 2009.

Auchincloss and McIntyre begin their article with two hypothetical situations involving special needs teachers using the iPod Touch to integrate technology into the lesson and make the information more accessible to students with varied learning needs. They describe the touch screen that makes the iPod Touch radically different from the iPod but still compatible with almost all the old applications. Also, the device is infinitely customizable for personal and educational needs.
Because of the large screen, Santa Clara University, as mentioned in the first article on using the iTouch as an educational tool, was able to download lectures onto it. The iTouch is also portable, which means that it can be used outside the classroom. According to a study on dyslexic students, having electronic support at home was a huge advantage.
Auchincloss and McIntyre continue by describing two widely known pieces of classroom technology, the SMART Board, a large interactive display and the Kurzweil 3000, a powerful text to speech program, and explain why the iPod Touch could replace both of them. They believe that the iPod Touch provides the interactivity of the SMART Board as well as the speech capabilities of the Kurzweil 3000 without the expense. They do admit that it could be a little more complicated to enter the text into the iTouch, since it doesn't scan like the Kurzweil 3000, but suggest a couple of workarounds, including using prepared audio/text books.
Having convinced the reader of the savings and value of the iTouch, the authors spend the last section of the article explaining how to set up mass iTouch usage at a school in three steps; device activation and familiarization, curriculum integration and preparation of iPod Touch materials, and introduction and integration during the school year. Finally, they recap the savings of the iTouch and its similarity to the SMART Board and the Kurzweil 3000, noting that even though the iTouch is new, there is enough research on the devices it replaces to know its value.

Patten, Kathryn B., and Dorothy Valcarcel Craig. "iPods and English-Language Learners: A Great Combination." Teacher Librarian 34.5 (2007): 40-4. Education Full Text. Web. 5 Nov. 2009.


Patten and Craig examine four classrooms with a high number of ELLs (English Language Learners) in which the teachers used an iPod based curriculum. They examine each classroom in turn, looking at the number of ELLs, the literature read, the responses of the teachers and students and their test scores before and after the school year. The authors suggest that the iPod fulfills two important functions as a piece of emerging technology and as a cultural tool, both of which are important to children trying to assimilate into an English speaking school. The iPod is a popular technology with good potential as teaching tool, and is used most often for podcasting and for learning another language.
In the study, each student had an iPod with an audio version of the written text to listen to, and had other assignments, depending on the classroom. Some students journalled, some answered quizzes or open ended questions, and all took various standardized tests afterward. In each classroom, there was clear improvement by the end of the year, as shown by test scores and by vocabulary usage and descriptive language in journals. While these improvements could have resulted from the lesson without iPods, it was significant that ELLs who chose to be in a regular English class did not do well on these tests, while less advanced Ells in the iPod classes did quite well.
The authors note a few issues, including what they call the earbud factor and the hot factor, and potential cost and copyright problems. The children were unable to use the earbuds and had to have headphones. Also, children initially were more inclined to play with and brag about their iPods than use them for the lesson. Copyright issues could drive up the cost, since each copy of the audio text can need a separate license. Using books from audible.com can work around that problem.
Although the study covers only a small sample and some of the results are inconclusive, it's clear that the iPod can be a valuable part of the curriculum.

Harris, Christopher. "An iPhone for Every Student." School Library Journal 54.11 (2008): 22. Library Lit & Inf Full Text. Web. 5 Nov. 2009.


Christopher Harris is a firm believer in the use of iPhones/iPods in the classroom and library. He rejects the traditional idea of one laptop for every child, because of the terrible battery life and the cost, in favor of an iPod per child. Even without a keyboard, he suggests that the iPod's flexibility, portability and open platform make it the best choice. He suggests that the iPod might be a better choice than the iPhone because it doesn't have a camera, but either way that the devices are the best handheld computers around with the most potential for classroom use.